Was reading an essay on lotr as a defense of Western Civilization.
This first excerpt is from a segment on The Fall being a cornerstone of Western literary tradition.
Considering that several of these gentlemen came to power after Tolkien had written his magnum opus, it’s easy to see why he found himself increasingly an anarchist.
the man who spents hundreds of pages describing trees and meals and worked out the linguistics of multiple fictional languages and the entire cosmology of his fictionsl world called the Beatles’ rehearsal sounds “indescribable”
all those obviously-allegorical christian fantasy stories are like really really cringy bible fanfiction
I’m not sure how Lewis managed to thread the needle to have a blatant allegory that’s also a good story, but people have been trying to copy him for decades with no success.
What about Tolkien?
I think he said his work was Catholic but not allegorical
Yeah I think there is a quote of his floating around, about how he started writing the stories as their own thing but realized that he has subconsciously tied in Catholic themes and beliefs into the world’s method and plot.
I realized a while back that “bear” in “Ringbearer” can mean not only “to carry” but “to tolerate or withstand” and I don’t think this is accidental, coming from Tolkien.
If language is involved, nothing involving Tolkien is ever accidental.
“You look at trees and called them ‘trees,’ and probably you do not think twice about the word. You call a star a ‘star,’ and think nothing more of it. But you must remember that these words, ‘tree,’ ‘star,’ were (in their original forms) names given to these objects by people with very different views from yours. To you, a tree is simply a vegetable organism, and a star simply a ball of inanimate matter moving along a mathematical course. But the first men to talk of ‘trees’ and ‘stars’ saw things very differently. To them, the world was alive with mythological beings. They saw the stars as living silver, bursting into flame in answer to the eternal music. They saw the sky as a jeweled tent, and the earth as the womb whence all living things have come. To them, the whole of creation was ‘myth-woven and elf patterned’.”
— J.R.R. Tolkien, from ‘Mythopoeia’ (via bulgakeov)